Great Plains Studies, Center for
Date of this Version
August 1994
Abstract
The authors have written an enlightening historical ethnography of the Willie Boy episode. By illuminating the frontier myth and Indian-hating inherent in the dominant story of Willie Boy, and using Chemehuevi ethnographic literature and oral traditions, Sandos and Burgess have separated myth from fact. This permitted them to develop a new white version based on historical documents. Importantly, they also present a Chemehuevi version of Willie Boy's tale. Additionally they present Willie Boy's own story relating to the episode.
In examining the development of the Willie Boy tale, including the stories told in Harry Lawton's book Willie Boy: A Desert Manhunt and Abraham Polonsky's film Tell Them Willie Boy Is Here, Sandos and Burgess show how Indian hating "shaped" the talc into a "triumph" of civilization over savagery. The authors persuasively argue that Willie Boy was not drunk when he killed William Mike. The story of alcohol involvement was accepted because it fit the stereotype of Indians who turned to liquor to solve their problems. Sandos and Burgess also suggest that one of the Indian trackers accidently killed Carlota.
Comments
Published in Great Plains Research 4:2 (August 1994). Copyright © 1994 The Center for Great Plains Studies, University of Nebraska–Lincoln. Used by permission. http://www.unl.edu/plains/publications/GPR/gpr.shtml