Off-campus UNL users: To download campus access dissertations, please use the following link to log into our proxy server with your NU ID and password. When you are done browsing please remember to return to this page and log out.
Non-UNL users: Please talk to your librarian about requesting this dissertation through interlibrary loan.
Faith as a Process: On Reconciling Faith and Doubt
There seems to be a growing consensus among philosophers of religion that Christian faith is compatible with doubt. In this dissertation, I posit some ways to conceive of such reconciliation. My general proposal is to construe faith as a kind of process—i.e., faith is something that grows in the person who has it. This process model applies to the cognitive dimension of faith too. In the first paper, I draw inspiration from the literatures on epistemic virtues. I maintain that faith, as an intellectual virtue, is congenial to the aim of securing firm belief—a cognitive state that seems to be endorsed as an ideal, if not a norm in the Christian tradition. Under this view, doubt can be compatible with faith if it is seen as a stage in the process of securing belief. From this suggestion, I then attempt to reconcile the conflicting claims of those who say that faith entails belief and those who argue otherwise. In the second paper, I focus on the cases of serious doubt - the kind of doubt that seems to be commensurate with disbelief. Considering the standards of substantive and structural theories of rationality, I argue that one is not being irrational for maintaining faith despite experiencing serious doubts. However, I also posit that, diachronically, it would be ideally rational for her to aspire for doxastic faith given the latter’s normative status. In the third paper, I consider the place of suspending judgment towards p (which is also doubt) in faith. I argue that such kind of doubt is not “sinful” if it were taken as a process whereby one is considering carefully and responding properly to the incommensurability of reasons involved.
Philosophy|Philosophy of religion|Epistemology
Del Rosario, John Paul Y, "Faith as a Process: On Reconciling Faith and Doubt" (2023). ETD collection for University of Nebraska - Lincoln. AAI30426992.