Optimal bait density for delivery of acute toxicants to vertebrate pests

Authors

Kim M. Pepin, USA National Wildlife Research Center, USDA-APHISFollow
Nathan P. Snow, USA National Wildlife Research Center, USDA-APHISFollow
Kurt C. VerCauteren, USA National Wildlife Research Center, USDA-APHISFollow

ORCID IDs

http://orcid.org/0000-0002-9931-8312

Document Type

Article

Date of this Version

1-27-2020

Citation

This is a U.S. Government work

Comments

Journal of Pest Science (2020) 93:723–735 https://doi.org/10.1007/s10340-020-01196-9

Abstract

Oral baiting is a fundamental method for delivering toxicants to pest species. Planning baiting strategies is challenging because bait-consumption rates depend on dynamic processes including space use and demographics of the target species. To determine cost-effective strategies for optimizing baiting, we developed a spatially explicit model of population dynamics using field-based measures of wild-pig (Sus scrofa) space use, bait consumption, and mortality probabilities. The most cost-effective baiting strategy depended strongly on the population reduction objective and initial density. A wide range of baiting strategies were cost-effective when the objective was 80% population reduction. In contrast, only a narrow range of baiting strategies allowed for a 99% reduction. Cost-effectiveness was lower for low densities of wild pigs because of the increased effort for locating target animals. Bait avoidance due to aversive conditioning from sub-lethal dosing had only minor effects on cost-effectiveness when the objective was an 80% reduction, whereas the effect was much stronger when the objective was 99% population reduction. Our results showed that a bait-based toxicant could be cost-effective for substantially reducing populations of wild pigs, but for elimination it may be most cost-effective to integrate additional management techniques following initial toxicant deployment. The nonlinear interaction of cost-effectiveness, initial population size, and reduction objective also emphasized the importance of considering the dynamics of space use and bait consumption for predicting effective baiting strategies. Although we used data for an acute toxicant and wild-pig consumption rates, our framework can be readily adapted to other vertebrate pest species and toxicant characteristics.