Evaluation of a New Strategy for Control of Bovine Tuberculosis in Michigan White-Tailed Deer: Year 1 Progress Report

Authors

Stephen Schmitt, Wildlife Division, Michigan Department of Natural Resources, MI, USA
Daniel O'Brien, Wildlife Division, Michigan Department of Natural Resources, MI, USA
Elaine Carlson, Wildlife Division, Michigan Department of Natural Resources, MI, USA
David Smith, Wildlife Division, Michigan Department of Natural Resources, MI, USA
Zachary Cooley, Wildlife Division, Michigan Department of Natural Resources, MI, USA
Brent Rudolph, Wildlife Division, Michigan Department of Natural Resources, MI, USA
Graham Hickling, Department of Fisheries & Wildlife, Michigan State University, MI, USA
Graham Nugent, Manaaki Whenua Landcare Research Ltd., New Zealand
Peter Butchko, USDA, APHIS, Wildlife Services, MI, USA

Date of this Version

2005

Comments

Published in Proceedings of the 11th Wildlife Damage Management Conference. (D.L. Nolte, K.A. Fagerstone, Eds). 2005.

Abstract

The State of Michigan is striving to eliminate bovine tuberculosis (Tb) infection among free-ranging white-tailed deer in the northeastern Lower Peninsula of the state. Aggressive reduction in the overall deer population abundance may help to further reduce TB prevalence, but this course of action is unacceptable to many hunters and landowners. Targeted culling of sick deer would likely be far more acceptable to these stakeholders, so in the winter of 2003 the Michigan Department of Natural Resources pilot-trialed a new strategy based on live-trapping and Tb-testing of wild deer. The field study was conducted in a township with relatively high TB prevalence within Deer Management Unit 452 in the northeastern Lower Peninsula. Over a 2-month trapping period, 119 individual deer were live-trapped, blood sampled, fitted with a radio-collar, and released. A total of 31 of these deer were subsequently classified as Tb-suspect by at least one of five blood tests employed (however there was a low level of agreement among tests). A delay in testing meant that only six of these suspect deer were culled by sharpshooters before pre-programmed release of their radio-collars, after which they could no longer be located. Mycobacterium bovis was cultured from one of these six suspect deer; the other five were negative on culture. All target deer were located to within shooting range with 1 – 2 days of effort, and all the radio-collars on the apparently-healthy deer dropped off after the intended 90-day interval, and were thereafter recovered for re-use. There was considerable support for this pilot project among hunters, farmers, state and federal agriculture agencies, the media and the general public, and so we recommend that further field trials be undertaken using this technique. The initial focus of these trials should be on improving the efficacy and reliability of the blood testing procedure.