Natural Resources, School of
School of Natural Resources: Faculty Publications
Accessibility Remediation
If you are unable to use this item in its current form due to accessibility barriers, you may request remediation through our remediation request form.
Make Forensic Case Reports Required Legal and Scientific Documents
ORCID IDs
Higley: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2949-7375
Simmons: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3445-8170
Document Type
Article
Date of this Version
2025
Citation
PNAS (2025) 122: e2406456122
doi: 10.1073/pnas.2406456122
Abstract
Forensic science in the United States has a problem. Watch a crime-solving television show, and you might see “reports from the lab” brandished as case-cracking paperwork. But in the real world, much of the evidence, data, and analysis that forensic scientists produce is never written down in a systematic way.
. . .
We experts are afforded special status by court because of our technical competency and are expected to testify solely based on this competency. Therefore, experts are not advocates, and experts do not win or lose cases. Indeed, it’s unethical for an expert to act as an advocate, or to appear as such, because doing so compromises their objectivity. Written case reports would reinforce the basis of this objectivity.
Comments
Open access
License: CC BY-NC-ND 4.0