Reconciling estimates of the contemporary North American carbon balance among terrestrial biosphere models, atmospheric inversions, and a new approach for estimating net ecosystem exchange from inventory-based data

Authors

Daniel J. Hayes, Oak Ridge National LaboratoryFollow
David P. Turner, Oregon State UniversityFollow
Graham Stinson, Canadian Forest ServiceFollow
A. David Mcguire, U.S. Geological Survey
Yaxing Wei, Oak Ridge National LaboratoryFollow
Tristram O. West, Joint Global Change Research InstituteFollow
Linda S. Heath, Global Environment FacilityFollow
Bernardus Dejong, El Colegio de la Frontera Sur
Brian G. Mcconkey, Agriculture and Agri-Food CanadaFollow
Richard A. Birdsey, USDA Forest Service, Newtown SquareFollow
Werner A. Kurz, Canadian Forest ServiceFollow
Andrew R. Jacobson, NOAA Earth System Research LabFollow
Deborah N. Huntzinger, Northern Arizona UniversityFollow
Yude Pan, USDA Forest Service, Newtown SquareFollow
W. Mac Post, Oak Ridge National Laboratory
Robert B. Cook, Oak Ridge National LaboratoryFollow

Document Type

Article

Date of this Version

2012

Citation

Global Change Biology (2012) 18, 1282–1299; doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2486.2011.02627.x

Abstract

We develop an approach for estimating net ecosystem exchange (NEE) using inventory-based information over North America (NA) for a recent 7-year period (ca. 2000–2006). The approach notably retains information on the spatial distribution of NEE, or the vertical exchange between land and atmosphere of all non-fossil fuel sources and sinks of CO₂, while accounting for lateral transfers of forest and crop products as well as their eventual emissions. The total NEE estimate of a -327 ± 252 TgC yr ^-1 sink for NA was driven primarily by CO₂ uptake in the Forest Lands sector (-248 TgC yr ^-1), largely in the Northwest and Southeast regions of the US, and in the Crop Lands sector (-297 TgC yr ^-1), predominantly in the Midwest US states. These sinks are counteracted by the carbon source estimated for the Other Lands sector (+218 TgC yr ^-1), where much of the forest and crop products are assumed to be returned to the atmosphere (through livestock and human consumption). The ecosystems of Mexico are estimated to be a small net source (+18 TgC yr ^-1) due to land use change between 1993 and 2002. We compare these inventory based estimates with results from a suite of terrestrial biosphere and atmospheric inversion models, where the mean continental-scale NEE estimate for each ensemble is -511 TgC yr ^-1 and -931 TgC yr ^-1, respectively. In the modeling approaches, all sectors, including Other Lands, were generally estimated to be a carbon sink, driven in part by assumed CO₂ fertilization and/or lack of consideration of carbon sources from disturbances and product emissions. Additional fluxes not measured by the inventories, although highly uncertain, could add an additional -239 TgC yr ^-1 to the inventory-based NA sink estimate, thus suggesting some convergence with the modeling approaches.