Abstract
I. Introduction
II. Al Maqaleh: Background and Procedural History … A. Facts of the Case ... B. The Four Major Opinions ... 1. Al Maqaleh I ... 2. Al Maqaleh II ... 3. Al Maqaleh III ... 4. Al Maqaleh IV
III. Revisiting the Site of Apprehension and Site of Detention Factors ... A. Site of Apprehension ... B. Site of Detention ... 1. Is Sovereignty a Necessary Condition for Writ Jurisdiction? ... a. De Facto Sovereignty ... b. Eistentrager’s Holding ... 2. Conflating Degree and Duration of Control ... 3. A “Permanent” U.S. Presence at Bagram
IV. When Practical Obstacles Become Practically Insurmountable ... A. Overstated Obstacles in Al Maqaleh: A Closer Inspection of the Facts ... B. Practical Obstacles as Separation of Powers Concerns
V. Executive Manipulation of Writ Jurisdiction ... A. Evidence of Manipulation ... B. The Senate Select Committee on Intelligence Report
VI. Conclusion: The Diminishing Reach of the Writ of Habeas Corpus
Recommended Citation
Rehan Abeyratne,
Al Maqaleh and the Diminishing Reach of Habeas Corpus,
95 Neb. L. Rev. 146
(2016)
Available at: https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/nlr/vol95/iss1/5